What Breaks Most: Failure Patterns from Our Bay Area Repairs

We’ve done over 27,000 repairs in Bay Area homes. These patterns come from about 17,000 of those jobs in our own job records. Refrigerators were the most common call (28% of jobs), and on refrigerators the problem customers reported most was the ice maker or water dispenser. Dryers came in mostly for not drying, and ranges and stoves mostly for a burner or igniter that was not working.

This page is Bay Appliance Repair’s own data, not a survey or a manufacturer study. It shows what we see on our calls. It is not a reliability ranking of brands.

The short version

  • Four appliances make up 74% of our calls: refrigerators (28%), washers (18%), dishwashers (16%) and dryers (12%).
  • Refrigerators: the ice maker or dispenser came up in 34% of fridge calls with a clear complaint (694 of 2,071), and an ice maker assembly was the part we named most often (23% of fridge jobs where a part was named).
  • Dryers: 46% of dryer complaints were about not drying or not heating. The part we named most was a belt, roller or idler (21%).
  • Ranges and stoves: 48% of complaints were a burner or igniter that was not working.
  • Microwaves: the magnetron, the part that makes the heat, was the part we named most (20% of microwave jobs with a named part).
  • Timing: the median wait from the request to our first visit was 3 days. Jobs where a part was ordered or installed took a median of 20 days to close, compared with 7 days for jobs with no part named.

Which appliances we were called for most

Share of about 17,000 job records by appliance type. Types with fewer than 30 jobs are left out.
ApplianceJobsShare
Refrigerator4,69528%
Washer3,01118%
Dishwasher2,74216%
Dryer2,07112%
Range / stove1,70910%
Wall oven7504%
Microwave7174%
Washer-dryer combo / stacked4242%
Cooktop2892%
Range hood / exhaust fan2231%
Freezer45<1%
Trash compactor44<1%
Wine / beverage cooler42<1%

Most of our calls are dispatched by manufacturers and home-warranty companies, so this mix reflects the work we are sent as well as how often things break.

The most common problems and parts, appliance by appliance

“Problem” is what the customer told us when they booked. “Part” is the part our technician ordered or installed, as written in the job notes. A job can have more than one problem, so the problem shares can add up to more than 100%.

Refrigerator

Refrigerator: reported problems, 2,071 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Ice maker / water dispenser69434%
Not cooling / not cold enough59829%
Leaking water32916%
Noise / vibration23811%
Frost / ice buildup1427%
Won't start / no power1357%
Refrigerator: parts ordered or installed, 1,600 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Ice maker assembly37023%
Fan motor / fan1368%
Control board / user interface1348%
Door boot / gasket / seal956%
Hinge / door parts886%

Washer

Washer: reported problems, 1,280 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Leaking water30724%
Noise / vibration30124%
Not draining / standing water21217%
Error code / controls / display18514%
Won't start / no power16613%
Not spinning / agitating / tumbling14211%
Washer: parts ordered or installed, 1,126 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Control board / user interface16615%
Drain pump16214%
Door boot / gasket / seal1009%
Suspension / shocks979%
Water inlet valve979%

Dishwasher

Dishwasher: reported problems, 1,053 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Error code / controls / display24323%
Not draining / standing water22521%
Won't start / no power21621%
Leaking water21320%
Not cleaning dishes10910%
Noise / vibration707%
Dishwasher: parts ordered or installed, 968 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Control board / user interface22623%
Drain pump10911%
Circulation / wash pump717%
Drive / wash motor626%
Water inlet valve616%

Dryer

Dryer: reported problems, 908 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Not drying / not heating41746%
Noise / vibration22725%
Won't start / no power12814%
Error code / controls / display9611%
Burning smell / gas smell313%
Dryer: parts ordered or installed, 831 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Belt / rollers / idler17321%
Heating element10613%
Control board / user interface8510%
Thermostat / thermistor / sensor8410%
Thermal fuse / cut-off455%

Range / stove

Range / stove: reported problems, 743 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Burner / igniter not working35648%
Error code / controls / display13718%
Won't start / no power11816%
Not heating10214%
Burning smell / gas smell446%
Noise / vibration416%
Range / stove: parts ordered or installed, 623 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Control board / user interface12119%
Igniter / spark module10317%
Heating element7212%
Door lock / latch / switch6811%
Burner / grate / cap539%

Wall oven

Wall oven: reported problems, 166 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Not heating5734%
Error code / controls / display4829%
Won't start / no power3420%
Wall oven: parts ordered or installed, 275 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Control board / user interface7728%
Igniter / spark module4617%

Microwave

Microwave: reported problems, 234 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Not heating8536%
Won't start / no power6327%
Error code / controls / display4318%
Microwave: parts ordered or installed, 341 jobs with a named part
PartJobsShare
Magnetron6820%
Control board / user interface5717%
Hinge / door parts4513%
Door lock / latch / switch3611%

Cooktop

Cooktop: reported problems, 61 jobs with a clear complaint
ProblemJobsShare
Burner / igniter not working4472%

Brand by brand: the problem we saw most

Only brand and appliance pairs with at least 30 clear complaints are shown. This is what we saw on our own jobs. It is not a reliability ranking: a brand with more calls may simply sell more units in the Bay Area or send us more warranty work.

Most common reported problem and most common named part, by brand and appliance
ApplianceBrandJobsTop reported problem (share of clear complaints)Top named part (share of jobs with a named part)
DishwasherGE853Won't start / no power (22% of 430)Control board / user interface (35% of 292)
DishwasherBosch446Error code / controls / display (49% of 170)Drain pump (17% of 137)
DishwasherKitchenAid201Not draining / standing water (25% of 55)Control board / user interface (16% of 77)
DishwasherWhirlpool189Leaking water (33% of 57)Drive / wash motor (15% of 84)
DishwasherFrigidaire149Not draining / standing water (29% of 63)Control board / user interface (25% of 65)
DishwasherSamsung124Error code / controls / display (45% of 38)Control board / user interface (15% of 41)
DryerGE534Not drying / not heating (48% of 329)Belt / rollers / idler (18% of 192)
DryerLG239Not drying / not heating (48% of 91)Belt / rollers / idler (30% of 89)
DryerWhirlpool235Not drying / not heating (39% of 97)Belt / rollers / idler (18% of 105)
DryerSamsung230Not drying / not heating (59% of 98)Belt / rollers / idler (33% of 110)
DryerMaytag213Not drying / not heating (43% of 82)Belt / rollers / idler (19% of 99)
DryerKenmore211Not drying / not heating (49% of 65)Belt / rollers / idler (19% of 85)
DryerElectrolux94Noise / vibration (51% of 59)Belt / rollers / idler (21% of 38)
MicrowaveGE308Not heating (37% of 119)Magnetron (21% of 152)
Range / stoveGE762Burner / igniter not working (49% of 384)Control board / user interface (19% of 263)
Range / stoveFrigidaire113Burner / igniter not working (31% of 58)Burner / grate / cap (21% of 43)
Range / stoveSamsung105Error code / controls / display (40% of 55)Control board / user interface (31% of 48)
Range / stoveWhirlpool80Burner / igniter not working (52% of 33)Heating element (23% of 44)
RefrigeratorGE971Not cooling / not cold enough (35% of 492)Ice maker assembly (14% of 347)
RefrigeratorSamsung607Ice maker / water dispenser (53% of 287)Ice maker assembly (36% of 292)
RefrigeratorWhirlpool460Ice maker / water dispenser (49% of 214)Ice maker assembly (26% of 170)
RefrigeratorLG456Ice maker / water dispenser (31% of 206)Ice maker assembly (23% of 145)
RefrigeratorFrigidaire384Not cooling / not cold enough (29% of 227)Ice maker assembly (17% of 118)
RefrigeratorKenmore294Not cooling / not cold enough (35% of 97)Ice maker assembly (23% of 97)
RefrigeratorKitchenAid230Ice maker / water dispenser (42% of 78)Ice maker assembly (19% of 89)
RefrigeratorSub-Zero153Leaking water (35% of 37)Fewer than 30 jobs with a named part
RefrigeratorBosch116Ice maker / water dispenser (65% of 65)Ice maker assembly (45% of 44)
RefrigeratorMonogram111Not cooling / not cold enough (37% of 41)Light / LED / bulb (15% of 33)
RefrigeratorSummit51Not cooling / not cold enough (31% of 32)Fewer than 30 jobs with a named part
WasherGE831Leaking water (26% of 455)Control board / user interface (19% of 279)
WasherSamsung375Noise / vibration (31% of 160)Suspension / shocks (25% of 167)
WasherLG373Leaking water (36% of 151)Drain pump (28% of 148)
WasherWhirlpool354Noise / vibration (25% of 131)Control board / user interface (15% of 144)
WasherMaytag330Noise / vibration (29% of 120)Control board / user interface (22% of 120)
WasherKenmore254Won't start / no power (36% of 83)Drain pump (14% of 97)
WasherElectrolux102Leaking water (37% of 49)Door boot / gasket / seal (33% of 33)
Washer-dryer combo / stackedGE322Noise / vibration (24% of 187)Door lock / latch / switch (17% of 95)

How long repairs take

Across the about 17,000 jobs in this data, the median time from the service request to our first visit was 3 days, and 42% of first visits happened within 2 days. The biggest factor in total time is parts. When a part was ordered or installed, the median job took 20 days from request to close. When no part was named, the median was 7 days. “Close” is the day the job was marked complete in our system, which can include warranty paperwork after the repair itself.

Median days by appliance (appliances with at least 30 jobs)
ApplianceJobsMedian days to first visitMedian days to closeClosed the same day as the first visit
All jobs16,94931121%
Cooktop28931312%
Dishwasher2,74231122%
Dryer2,07131122%
Freezer453921%
Microwave71731314%
Range / stove1,70931223%
Range hood / exhaust fan22331222%
Refrigerator4,69531121%
Trash compactor4431219%
Wall oven75031412%
Washer3,01131123%
Washer-dryer combo / stacked4243833%
Wine / beverage cooler4248.529%

What this means if something just broke

  • Have the model number ready. In our records, jobs that needed a part took much longer than jobs that did not. The model and serial number help the technician identify the right part.
  • Fridge ice maker out but the fridge still cold? That matches the pattern we see most on fridges. If the fridge is still holding temperature, it is less urgent, but book a visit before a stuck valve or ice jam turns into a leak. See ice maker repair.
  • Dryer runs but clothes stay damp? Clean the lint screen and check the vent first. If it still will not heat, see dryer not heating.
  • Gas burner clicks but will not light? Turn the burner off and make sure the cap is seated. If you smell gas, leave the house and call your gas utility first. See gas stove won’t light.

Where these calls came from

Most calls were in San Francisco, the East Bay, the Peninsula, the South Bay and the North Bay. The ten cities with the most calls were San Francisco (3,363), Oakland (1,018), San Jose (866), Santa Rosa (666), Hayward (585), San Mateo (501), Concord (369), Walnut Creek (338), Napa (329), San Ramon (313). See all service areas.

How we counted (method and limits)

  • Source: Bay Appliance Repair’s own job records, exported from our ServiceDesk job system: 16,949 job records (about 17,000 of the over 27,000 repairs we have done), all in Bay Area homes.
  • Privacy: no customer names, addresses or phone numbers are shown. Locations are rolled up to city.
  • Appliance and brand: taken from the appliance type and brand on each job, with spelling variants grouped (for example “GENERAL ELECTRIC” and “GE”). Monogram and Café are counted separately from GE.
  • Problems: coded from the complaint recorded at booking, using a fixed keyword list. 61% of jobs had a usable complaint, and 41% of all jobs matched at least one problem category. Shares are out of the jobs that matched.
  • Parts: coded from part names our technicians wrote in the job notes when ordering or installing a part. 36% of jobs name at least one part. Some parts are not written by name, so these are lower bounds.
  • Minimum sample: any appliance, brand or problem group with fewer than 30 jobs is left out.
  • Who sends us work: most of these jobs came through manufacturers and home-warranty companies. That shapes which brands show up most.
  • No prices: this page reports failure patterns and timing only.
  • Models change: patterns can shift as manufacturers change designs, so treat these as what we have seen, not a forecast.

Questions about this data

What appliance breaks most often?

In our records, refrigerators. They were 28% of about 17,000 jobs in our records, followed by washers (18%), dishwashers (16%) and dryers (12%). Part of that mix comes from the warranty work we are sent.

What is the most common refrigerator problem?

The ice maker or water dispenser. It was part of 34% of refrigerator calls with a clear complaint (694 of 2,071). An ice maker assembly was also the part we named most on fridge jobs.

Why is my dryer not drying?

Not drying or not heating was 46% of dryer complaints in our records. Common causes include a clogged vent, a failed heating element, thermal fuse or thermostat on electric dryers, and an igniter or gas valve problem on gas dryers. Clean the lint screen and check the vent first.

How long does an appliance repair take?

In our records, the median wait from request to first visit was 3 days. Jobs that needed a part ordered took a median of 20 days to close, compared with 7 days when no part was named.

Is this a brand reliability ranking?

No. It shows what we see on our own calls. A brand that appears more often may simply have more units in Bay Area homes or send us more warranty work.

Where does this data come from?

From Bay Appliance Repair's own ServiceDesk job records: about 17,000 jobs in Bay Area homes, out of the over 27,000 repairs we have done. No customer details are published.

Something broken right now? Call (415) 585-5900 or book online

Mon to Fri, 8am to 5pm